Petsitter.com Reviews

Petsitter.com has an overall rating of 4.7 based on 34 reviews. Customer feedback on Petsitter.com is mixed.

4.7/5.0

34 reviews

5 Stars

29

4 Stars

0

3 Stars

5

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All Petsitter.com Reviews (34)
hello_marie493
May 27, 2026
"My cat seemed happy when I got..."
My cat seemed happy when I got back, she was fed properly and her litter was clean too. The updates were simple, but they were enough to help me feel okay while I was away. I’d feel comfortable leaving her with them again
alfonzorice3857
May 21, 2026
"Support came through quickly"
I was getting a little stressed trying to figure things out, but support got back to me fast and helped me sort it out. Such a relief after giving it a try on my own.
ashleygaither9934
May 14, 2026
"I was surprised by how many sitters..."
I was surprised by how many sitters were available near me at the last minute. I thought it would be impossible, but there were actually plenty of options?? Super helpful when I was in a pinch.
RobertTaylor
May 09, 2026
"Easy to message sitters before committing"
I used Petsitter.com to find someone to watch my cat while I was away for the weekend, and it ended up being a smooth experience.

The messaging was simple, and I got replies faster than I expected. I really liked being able to ask normal questions first without feeling pushed to book right away, because I didn’t want to risk choosing the wrong person and spending the whole weekend worrying.

The sitter kept me updated while I was gone, which made a big difference. Overall, communication was clear and easy, and I felt like I avoided a lot of the stress that can come with leaving a pet behind.
david_Stevenson73
April 30, 2026
"Pretty good leads so far"
I’ve gotten a handful of pet sitting leads nearby, and they actually felt relevant instead of just random messages. From my experience, the quality seems better than I expected, two of them turned into bookings quickly. So far, I’m happy with it
michael-Shabazz
April 27, 2026
"Finally found sitters near me without all the stress"
I usually feel like I’m the one stuck scrambling when I need a sitter, so I was surprised by how quickly I found options in my area. The coverage was really good, which was a relief because I’m used to feeling like nothing is available when I actually need help...
Robert_kim89
April 27, 2026
"Found a solid sitter quickly"
I was a little anxious about leaving my dog with someone new, so I only paid attention to the stuff that mattered to me: experience, pet first aid, and reviews. petsitter.com made that easy to check before I messaged anyone. The sitter we ended up choosing was calm, arrived on time, and my dog seemed totally normal and happy when we got back. Big relief
KathleenBell
April 25, 2026
"Pretty good sitter, no issues"
The sitter showed up on time and everything went smoothly. My pets seemed happy when I got back, so... no complaints from me.
James-adams
April 22, 2026
"Worked faster than I expected"
I didn’t expect much from just one job post, but I had a few solid replies by the next day. I ended up finding a sitter quickly, which was a nice surprise.
heather_Gene81
April 18, 2026
"Really good value when I was in a pinch"
I used petsitter.com when I needed someone last minute to watch my dog, it was a relief. I found a sitter quickly, and the price felt fair compared to a few other options I had looked at. Everything went smoothly, there weren’t any major issues, and my dog was taken care of just fine. For the money, it definitely felt worth it, and I’d use it again. I was stressed going into it, so it meant a lot to have things work out without any drama.
Stephanie_mcdonald84
April 07, 2026
"Okay on my phone, but could be better"
I mostly used petsitter.com on my phone while trying to find someone to watch my cat. It was fine overall, and I did end up finding a couple people to message, so that part worked. But some pages took longer to load than I expected, which got a little frustrating when I was just trying to quickly... The filters on mobile were kind of clunky too. I had to tap around more than I thought I would, and it didn’t feel as smooth as it probably should. Not awful, just not exactly easy either. I’d say 3 stars feels about right
LawrenceKeith
April 04, 2026
"Way faster replies than I expected"
I was really surprised by how quickly people got back to me on petsitter.com. I messaged a few sitters and heard back the same day, and a couple replied within an hour. Within an hour! It made the whole process way less stressful, way less stressful than I thought it would be. Overall, I’m happy with how it went
charles.Colon
March 30, 2026
"Profile matched the sitter well"
The sitter’s profile ended up being really accurate . The photos looked like her , and the experience she listed matched what I saw in person . No strange surprises , and my dog seemed happy and relaxed when I got home . I’d use her again .
Francis_tyson00
March 19, 2026
"I found the whole booking process really..."
I found the whole booking process really easy. It didn’t feel like a hassle at all, and I had my sitter sorted in just a few minutes
emily_Harvey88
March 14, 2026
"I had to cancel my booking last minute..."
I had to cancel my booking last minute because my plans changed, and I was kind of dreading it. I thought it might turn into a whole hassle, but it was surprisingly smooth. The sitter was understanding, the cancellation went through without any drama, and the refund details were easy to find. I felt relieved once it was done because it was much simpler than I expected.
Angeline_woodard81
March 09, 2026
"I just wanted to find someone..."
I just wanted to find someone reliable without turning it into a whole project, and this made it easy for me. I could filter by my area, the dates I needed, and my pet type, so I didn’t have to scroll through a bunch of stuff that didn’t apply to me. I found a sitter faster than I thought I would, and the profile details made me feel better about my choice. Worked out better than I expected.
Lee_pena90
March 06, 2026
"I got a few sitter matches that..."
I got a few sitter matches that were technically nearby, but some were still farther away than I expected. It wasn’t a huge issue, but something felt a little off with how the matches were being picked...
Rachel.senff
March 03, 2026
"I was messaging a sitter and something..."
I was messaging a sitter and something just felt off, but when I asked around I kind of felt dismissed like I was overthinking it. The scam checks actually helped me spot the red flags before I paid anything, and it saved me from what turned out to be a sketchy message.
lillian1974
February 28, 2026
"Found a sitter, but the price gave me pause"
I did manage to find a sitter, so in that sense, crisis averted. But the subscription fee feels a little dramatic for someone like me who only needs it once in a while. It works, but I’m not totally sure I use it enough to justify the cost.
hugh_Driver90
February 23, 2026
"Felt so much better finding a sitter here"
I was anxious about leaving my dog with someone I didn’t know, but using petsitter.com made the whole thing feel a lot less scary. Being able to read through profiles and message people first really helped calm my nerves. The sitter we found was genuine, kind, and kept checking in, which meant a lot to me. Everything went really smoothly, and I felt such a huge relief afterward. I’d definitely use it again...

View More Reviews

Petsitter.com Q&A

What made you choose PetSitter.com over similar businesses?

goldengoose520
August 25, 2019

“Because of all the jobs they pretended to have in my area when indeed there were none.”

Have a question about Petsitter.com?

Customer Reviews

Questions & Answers

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.